Sunday, 5 January 2014

NSA monitored calls of 35 world leaders after US official handed over contacts

Agency given more than 200 numbers by government official 
SID_460View larger picture
The NSA memo suggests that such surveillance was not isolated as the agency routinely monitors world leaders. Photograph: Guardian
The National Security Agency monitored the phone conversations of 35 world leaders after being given the numbers by an official in another US government department, according to a classified document provided by whistleblower Edward Snowden.
The confidential memo reveals that the NSA encourages senior officials in its "customer" departments, such as the White House, State and the Pentagon, to share their "Rolodexes" so the agency can add the phone numbers of leading foreign politicians to their surveillance systems.
The document notes that one unnamed US official handed over 200 numbers, including those of the 35 world leaders, none of whom is named. These were immediately "tasked" for monitoring by the NSA.
The revelation is set to add to mounting diplomatic tensions between the US and its allies, after the German chancellor Angela Merkel on Wednesday accused the US of tapping her mobile phone.
After Merkel's allegations became public, White House press secretary Jay Carney issued a statement that said the US "is not monitoring and will not monitor" the German chancellor's communications. But that failed to quell the row, as officials in Berlin quickly pointed out that the US did not deny monitoring the phone in the past.
Arriving in Brussels for an EU summit Merkel accused the US of a breach of trust. "We need to have trust in our allies and partners, and this must now be established once again. I repeat that spying among friends is not at all acceptable against anyone, and that goes for every citizen in Germany."
The NSA memo obtained by the Guardian suggests that such surveillance was not isolated, as the agency routinely monitors the phone numbers of world leaders – and even asks for the assistance of other US officials to do so.
The memo, dated October 2006 and which was issued to staff in the agency's Signals Intelligence Directorate (SID), was titled "Customers Can Help SID Obtain Targetable Phone Numbers".
It begins by setting out an example of how US officials who mixed with world leaders and politicians could help agency surveillance.
"In one recent case," the memo notes, "a US official provided NSA with 200 phone numbers to 35 world leaders … Despite the fact that the majority is probably available via open source, the PCs [intelligence production centers] have noted 43 previously unknown phone numbers. These numbers plus several others have been tasked."
The document continues by saying the new phone numbers had helped the agency discover still more new contact details to add to their monitoring: "These numbers have provided lead information to other numbers that have subsequently been tasked."
But the memo acknowledges that eavesdropping on the numbers had produced "little reportable intelligence". In the wake of the Merkel row, the US is facing growing international criticism that any intelligence benefit from spying on friendly governments is far outweighed by the potential diplomatic damage.
The memo then asks analysts to think about any customers they currently serve who might similarly be happy to turn over details of their contacts.
"This success leads S2 [signals intelligence] to wonder if there are NSAliaisons whose supported customers may be willing to share their 'Rolodexes' or phone lists with NSA as potential sources of intelligence," it states. "S2 welcomes such information!"
The document suggests that sometimes these offers come unsolicited, with US "customers" spontaneously offering the agency access to their overseas networks.
"From time to time, SID is offered access to the personal contact databases of US officials," it states. "Such 'Rolodexes' may contain contact information for foreign political or military leaders, to include direct line, fax, residence and cellular numbers."
The Guardian approached the Obama administration for comment on the latest document. Officials declined to respond directly to the new material, instead referring to comments delivered by Carney at Thursday's daily briefing.
Carney told reporters: "The [NSA] revelations have clearly caused tension in our relationships with some countries, and we are dealing with that through diplomatic channels.
"These are very important relations both economically and for our security, and we will work to maintain the closest possible ties."
The public accusation of spying on Merkel adds to mounting political tensions in Europe about the scope of US surveillance on the governments of its allies, after a cascade of backlashes and apologetic phone calls with leaders across the continent over the course of the week.
Asked on Wednesday evening if the NSA had in the past tracked the German chancellor's communications, Caitlin Hayden, the White House's National Security Council spokeswoman, said: "The United States is not monitoring and will not monitor the communications of Chancellor Merkel. Beyond that, I'm not in a position to comment publicly on every specific alleged intelligence activity."
At the daily briefing on Thursday, Carney again refused to answer repeated questions about whether the US had spied on Merkel's calls in the past.
The NSA memo seen by the Guardian was written halfway through George W Bush's second term, when Condoleezza Rice was secretary of state and Donald Rumsfeld was in his final months as defence secretary.
Merkel, who, according to Reuters, suspected the surveillance after finding her mobile phone number written on a US document, is said to have called for US surveillance to be placed on a new legal footing during a phone call to President Obama.
"The [German] federal government, as a close ally and partner of the US, expects in the future a clear contractual basis for the activity of the services and their co-operation," she told the president.
The leader of Germany's Green party, Katrin Goring-Eckhart, called the alleged spying an "unprecedented breach of trust" between the two countries.
Earlier in the week, Obama called the French president François Hollande in response to reports in Le Monde that the NSA accessed more than 70m phone records of French citizens in a single 30-day period, while earlier reports in Der Spiegel uncovered NSA activity against the offices and communications of senior officials of the European Union.
The European Commission, the executive body of the EU, this week backed proposals that could require US tech companies to seek permission before handing over EU citizens' data to US intelligence agencies, while the European parliament voted in favour of suspending a transatlantic bank data sharing agreement after Der Spiegel revealed the agency was monitoring the international bank transfer system Swift.

UK storms 'worst in 20 years', and more on the way

Weather experts predict more flooding, with 96 warnings for England and Wales on Sunday and another storm due
Buildings surrounded by floods near Tewkesbury after the Severn burst its banks.
Buildings surrounded by floods near Tewkesbury after the Severn burst its banks. Photograph: Demotix/Corbis
The UK is enduring the worst series of winter storms in more than 20 years, weather experts have said, as the country prepares for even more flooding.
The Environment Agency has issued 96 flood warnings throughout England and Wales urging people to take immediate action, while a further 244 areas are on flood alert.
Coastal areas – particularly in southern England – are most at risk as they cope with a combination of unusually high tides and another Atlantic storm on Sunday.
Forecaster Matt Dobson for MeteoGroup said the rain "simply has nowhere to go" after weeks of severe weather has saturated the ground and swelled rivers.
"It's very unusual to have so many powerful storms come in one after the other in such a short space of time, he said. "We haven't seen anything like this since about 1991.
"The nasty weather of the last few days is going to continue across the UK, with the combination of high tides and a powerful storm putting coastal areas particularly at risk.
"Any rain will mean more flooding as the ground is saturated and swollen rivers are coming up against strong waves. The water simply has nowhere to go."
The Met Office has issued yellow weather warnings of ice and rain, predicting river and surface flooding as well as travel disruption mainly in south Wales and the south west and south east of England. Up to 40mm of rain could fall in higher ground.
Inland rainfall will put pressure on rivers, particularly the Medway in Kent, the Thames in Oxford and Osney and the Severn Estuary in Gloucestershire.
The Thames barrier will remain closed to protect land near the river.
Strong winds, persistent rain and tidal waves are predicted for at least another two days, as emergency services attempt to cope with the trail of devastation already created by the severe weather.
More than 200 homes have been flooded from Cornwall to Scotland, with miles of coastline battered and roads and fields across the country left under water.
The prime minister, David Cameron, praised the "great work" of the emergency services and Environment Agency in responding to the latest floods and defended the government's flooding policy in protecting 200,000 homes.
Meanwhile, searches resumed in south Devon for missing 18-year-old university student Harry Martin who was last seen leaving his home to take photographs of the weather, with more than 100 people volunteering to look for him.
Officials around the country have pleaded with people to keep away as dozens put their life at risk by going to coastal areas to watch as the storm brought waves up to 40ft high crashing on to land.
A man and child were almost swept away by a huge wave at Mullion Cove in Cornwall as they peered over the sea wall to watch the raging sea, and elsewhere in Cornwall vehicles driving on a coastal road were swamped and almost washed away by a tidal surge.
Elsewhere in Cornwall, Sergeant Regie Butler pulled a man who had been drinking from the sea at Towan Beach, Newquay, after he had ignored police warnings.
In Aberystwyth, Dyfed a man was rescued by lifeboat after he defied police warnings and became trapped when photographing waves from a harbour jetty.
In the town debris was strewn across the promenade, rail lines in north Wales were left buckled by the power of the sea and a road collapsed in Amroth, Pembrokeshire.
The strong tides were said to be the worst to hit the Welsh coast in 15 years.
Aberystwyth University has deferred the start of exams by a week and was advising students not to travel to the coastal town until the middle of next week.
Emergency services rescued four people from a flooded farm in Llanbedr near Barmouth, north-west Wales, the Severn burst its banks in Gloucestershire for the second day running and a pregnant woman was rescued after 30 properties were flooded in Cardigan, mid-Wales. Part of the sea wall behind the Landmark Theatre in Ilfracombe collapsed because of the storms.
The environment secretary, Owen Paterson, said: "The worst of the bad weather is not yet over so I've chaired an emergency meeting of all departments involved to make sure that preparations to respond are in hand.
"Our flood defences have worked very well and have protected 205,000 homes at risk."

Teenager arrested after police find suspected explosives at house in Hull

Residents say 'all hell broke loose' when army bomb disposal experts arrived at residential home in early hours of Sunday
Police tape
The teenager was arrested along with a 49-year-old woman and a 56-year-old man. Photograph: Arthur Turner/Alamy
A 15-year-old boy has been arrested after suspected explosive substances were found at a house in Hull.
Army bomb disposal experts were called to the terraced council property along with scores of police, firefighters and paramedics following a tip-off. A number of families were moved out of their homes as a precaution.
The teenager was arrested in the early hours of Sunday morning along with a 49-year-old woman and a 56-year-old man.
A multi-agency operation, led by Humberside police, was continued into the night, more than 15 hours after officers arrived in Kilnsea Grove in the east of the city.
Some of those evacuated were let back into their properties after the bomb disposal team left on Sunday afternoon but a handful of homes remained cordoned off.
A number of police and fire service vehicles were still parked outside the house and officers have erected a blue forensics tent on the road in front of the property.
Earlier, dozens of people living in the area gathered behind the police cordon to watch the soldiers go into the property.
One man said: "I can't believe what descended on us. There's army, police, ambulances, four-wheel drive ambulances, fire engines. Everything's here.
"They came in the middle of the night after a tip-off about stuff in the house. Then all hell broke loose. I've not seen anything like it."
Another Kilnsea Grove resident said: "They've just said they've found explosives inside and we're to stay well away. They've got everyone out just in case. You can't be too careful."
A Humberside police spokesman said they received a call at 2.49am on Sunday and confirmed they were "investigating a report of substance(s) which are believed to be inside a residential property".
The spokesman said the army's explosives ordnance disposal unit had been deployed as part of a multi-agency response.
Detective Inspector Jason Gourley said: "Our officers arrived at an address in east Hull in the early hours of today.
"Since then, we have arrested three people who are currently assisting us with our enquiries in connection with substances believed to be at a property on Kilnsea Grove.
"We are working closely with our partner agencies to ensure the area is safe for the local community, which is why we have put a cordon in place.
"We hope that residents can return to their properties as quickly as possible, but public safety is paramount, so we hope that everyone will obey the police cordons and we will let them know when the police has finished carrying out all relevant enquiries."
The incident is not being treated as terrorist-related, police said.Bomb disposal experts, police and firefighters are assessing a house in Hull where "substances" have been found, and a number of nearby properties have been evacuated.
Humberside police said a 15-year-old boy, a 49-year-old woman and a 56-year-old man were arrested after officers were called to the address in Kilnsea Grove at 2.49am.
A spokesman said: "A police cordon is currently in place and a small number of properties in the vicinity have been evacuated by the police and Humberside fire and rescue as a routine precaution."
The spokesman said the army's explosives ordnance disposal unit had been deployed. He said they were "investigating a report of substance(s) which are believed to be inside a residential property".
Members of the public have been advised not to go near the area and to observe the cordon in place. DI Jason Gourley, of Humberside police, said: "We are working closely with our partner agencies to ensure the area is safe for the local community, which is why we have put a cordon in place.
"We hope that residents can return to their properties as quickly as possible, but public safety is paramount, so we hope that everyone will obey the police cordons and we will let them know when the police has finished carrying out all relevant inquiries."
Police said the incident was not being treated as terrorism-related.

Scottish Power to cut prices by 3.3%


Typical dual bills will be reduced by around £42, after criticism the firm failed to pass on reductions agreed with government
Scottish Power to cut prices by 3.3%
Scottish Power said: 'We are committed to delivering the reductions as agreed with the government.' Photograph: David Cheskin/PA
Energy firm Scottish Power is planning to cut its prices by 3.3% following criticism that it had failed to pass on savings from the government's rolling back of green levies that were added to power bills.
The move will reduce typical household gas and electricity dual fuel bills by around £42 and Scottish Power is also expected to pass on a further £12 rebate to all customers for the Warm Home Discount, which the government has said will be funded through general taxation instead of through levies on energy bills.
A spokesman for Scottish Power said: "We are committed to delivering the reductions as agreed with the government and will make an announcement this week."
The tariff cut will only partly reverse increases of 8.5% and 9% for gas and electricity respectively from Scottish Power a month ago.
The expected move follows the a New Year's Day bill reduction by British Gas of 3.2%.

Christmas storms: power company to boost compensation


UK Power Networks offers to almost triple payouts to worst-off victims of harsh weather, as flood warnings remain in place
Flooded streets in Tonbridge, Kent. Weekend showers are likely to hamper clean-up operations
Flooded streets in Tonbridge, Kent. Weekend showers are likely to hamper clean-up operations. Photograph: Saeed Malik/Demotix/Corbis
One of the UK's biggest power distributors is to almost triple its compensation for those affected by long-term power cuts as a result of the Christmas storms.
UK Power Networks, which owns electricity lines and cables in London, the south-east and east of England, said that when high winds struck on Thursday night, power was initially interrupted to more than 300,000 of its 8 million customers. The company said on Saturday that 663 customers in Kent, 97 in Surrey and 326 in Sussex were still without power.
Electricity North West said 1,600 customers were still without power in Cumbria on Saturday after engineers restored power to more than 20,000 properties across the region
The director of customer services for UK Power Networks, Matt Rudling, said: "This is such a difficult time of year for people to be without power and so many families have also been flooded out of their homes.
"Our hearts go out to our customers and we have been trying different ways to help them, from arranging Christmas dinners to providing more help and tools on our website."
A spokesman added: "As a gesture of goodwill UK Power Networks has decided to boost the industry standard payment from £27 to £75 for customers who are without power for 48-60 hours including Christmas Day, and additional payments will be made to any customers off supply for longer up to a maximum of £432."
The offer came as scores of flood warnings remained in place across the UK, with more showers this weekend likely to further delay clean-up operations.
Forecasters said the mild wet and blustery weather would be a respite from the two major storms endured over Christmas, which left thousands of homes flooded and many without power for days.
The Environment Agency has issued more than 130 flood alerts across central and southern England – with 34 urging residents to take immediate action.
Showers would mainly affect western and southern England, Wales and parts of Scotland before a light storm moved in on Sunday, Meteogroup forecaster Sean Penston said.
"It won't be nearly as bad compared to the last two storms but it will no doubt make it hard for people recovering from flooding," he said.
The authorities' efforts to deal with the chaos caused by the first storm on Monday were hampered by the arrival of a second storm on Boxing Day night, bringing with it gales of more than 100mph.
On Friday, power companies were condemned for failing to restore supplies to thousands of people – some of whom had been without electricity since Christmas Eve.
More than 1,200 homes flooded, while many rivers burst there banks and groundwater flooding made roads impassable. The floods, and fallen trees and debris caused major airport, rail and road disruptions.
The Energy Networks Association (ENA) said on Friday that 13,000 homes were still without power across the south of England and Wales. About 5,000 customers in Northern Ireland were without electricity, while around 35,000 homes across Ireland had no power on Friday night.
In Kent, David Cameron was confronted by angry flood victims as he visited Yalding, a village seriously affected by the latest storms.
ENA spokesman Tony Glover apologised to those affected by the storms, but highlighted the difficulties technicians had been facing.
"The problem was that not only did we have a storm followed by torrential rain, but huge amounts of flooding afterwards. That impacted on our ability to get to the affected areas, and to get materials that we need."
ScottishPower said it had now reconnected 14,500 customers who lost power during Thursday night's storm.
Spokesman Simon McMillan said: "The biggest issue affecting the electricity network has been uprooted trees and other debris blown on to overhead power lines, which has caused damage and brought down the power lines in some areas.
"The company will do all that it can to restore supplies as quickly as possible. However, a number of roads and bridges have been blocked and closed by fallen trees which could restrict access in certain locations, and where wind speeds remain high engineers will not be able to climb poles and work at height."
Robin Gisby, managing director of network operations at Network Rail, said this week "has been one of the most challenging periods we have faced in recent times".
Thursday night's storms meant several trains were delayed on Friday morning so lines could be examined in daylight.
The line from London to Portsmouth via Haslemere is blocked by four landslips near Liphook, and will stay closed over the weekend. The track at Ockley, between Horsham and Dorking, is also closed after a serious landslip.
A spokesman for the Rail Delivery Group, which speaks for the rail industry, said: "We'd like to apologise to passengers whose journeys over the festive period have been affected by the bad weather of the last few days.
"Hundreds of rail staff have been working round the clock to clear tracks but some services have started later than planned to ensure passengers can complete their journeys safely."
North West Ambulance Service used Twitter to warn people about going outside in the gales. A spokeswoman said the service had taken half a dozen calls in Lancashire alone about people being blown over by the wind, though only minor injuries were reported.
The Conservative MP for Hastings and Rye, Amber Rudd, criticised Southeastern trains for failing to provide a replacement bus service for her constituents in the commuter belt towns.
While Southern Rail was offering workers the option of commuting to London via bus and even using Twitter to post regular updates, Southeastern services, including their communications, had been lamentable, she said.
"So Southern have really done very well," said Ms Rudd. "I think it's partly because they've got Gatwick airport on their tail wanting a better service. But Southeastern has not been anywhere near as good, and I have received a lot of complaints about them. They have been just too complacent."
The RAC reported a 20% increase in vehicle breakdowns across the UK, rising to a 40% increase in the south and south-east between Christmas Eve and Friday.
A combination of storms and floods, congestion caused by shoppers hitting the Boxing Day sales and those heading home after the Christmas break, had all contributed to the spike in breakdowns, it said.
"We are maintaining increased levels of both patrol and support team hours as we prepare for the onslaught of shoppers over the busy sale weekend," the spokeswoman Sarah Rice said. "The anticipated early return to work on Monday inevitably sees high volumes of breakdowns."
The RAC advised drivers to give cars a 5-mile drive to test the battery, check tyre pressures and tread, coolant and screen-wash levels, and ensure windscreen wipers were working properly.

Lewandowski won't force Mandzukic out - Rummenigge

Lewandowski won't force Mandzukic out - Rummenigge
As well as claiming that the Croat striker remains part of Pep Guardiola's plans, the Bayern chief rejected reports linking them with David Luiz
Bayern Munich chairman Karl-Heinz Rummenigge insists Mario Mandzukic has a future at the club despite them signing a deal with Robert Lewandowski on Saturday.

The striker, 27, who has scored of 10 Bundesliga goals this season, has been linked with a move away from the Allianz Arena in the summer, coinciding with Lewandowski's arrival from Borussia Dortmund on a free transfer.
However, Rummenigge has moved quickly to quash such speculation following confirmation of the contract with the Polish attacker, insisting that the Bavarians are in fact hoping to extend the Croat's current deal.
"We're very pleased with Mario," Rummenigge told Bayern's official website. "He made a significant contribution to us winning so many trophies last year.

"He's a great player who is thriving at Bayern. He has a contract with us until 30 June 2016, and I told his agent during the Club World Cup that we're willing to consider an early contract extension.
"It is by no means a topic of discussion that we want to sell Mario."
Chelsea defender David Luiz has been heavily linked with Pep Guardiola's squad, but Rummenigge claims that the reported interest has been invented as die Roten are not looking at bringing in the likes of the Brazil international this month.
"There's a lot of speculation at the moment, especially in England," the Bayern chief added. "We're being linked with David Luiz and a number of Spanish players.
"All I can say, very clearly, is bringing in these players is not of interest to us. We're not concerned about players we're being linked with joining next summer.
"There's nothing lined up, so we have nothing to hide. It's simply not an issue."
Bayern return to Bundesliga action, having lifted the Club Word Cup in December, on January 25 at Borussia Monchengladbach.

Madrid tabled 'immoral' Lewandowski offer, claims agent

Madrid tabled 'immoral' Lewandowski offer, claims agent
The attacker's representative has revealed that the Santiago Bernabeu side were keen to lure him to La Liga
Robert Lewandowski's agent Maik Barthel has claimed that Real Madrid attempted to hijack Bayern Munich's move for the Borussia Dortmund striker.

The Poland international signed a five-year deal with the Bundesliga champions on Saturday to bring a protracted transfer saga to an end.

However, Barthel has revealed that Madrid were keen to sign Lewandowski, too, and were willing to go far for the 25-year-old.

"There was an immoral offer from Real Madrid," the striker's representative was quoted as saying bySpiegel Online.

Madrid were reportedly willing to offer Lewandowski an annual salary of €9.5 million plus an additional €10m signing fee, but Barthel has made it clear that they never considered breaking their promise to Bayern.

He added: "We listened to their offer out of respect for such a big club. But breaking our word never crossed our mind."

Lewandowski has been in sublime form for Dortmund this season, scoring 11 goals in 17 Bundesliga appearances